Home › Forums › PDCEN Meetings › PDSIG June 2014 › Feedback from latest PDCEN – June 14

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #860
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Hi all,

    Please find below the feedback from the latest SIG / CEN, feel free to add your own comments below..

    Robin
    PDSIG/CEN web support

    CEN Feedback 10.06.2014

    Topic 1: Masters Project looking at Health psychology and Dysphagia

    The talk was interesting

    1 2 (1) 3 (7) 4 (33) 5 (34)

    The talk was relevant to my job

    1 2(1) 3(7) 4 (31) 5 (35) NR (1)

    Comments:
    •Thanks for the opportunity!
    •I’d like the decision and tool
    •Interesting and practical (6)
    •Shame not sharing presentation as SIG money was used for the project
    •Made me think we should all be making more contribution to research
    •Very useful and practical (4)
    •Very interesting to hear the psychology aspect and lots of questions about future research
    •Looking forward to the tool being developed! (4)
    •Something we are struggling with so interesting to hear how it is being tackled from a psychology point of view

    Topic 2: Taping for Drooling

    The talk was interesting

    1 2 (2) 3 (11) 4 (34) 5 (28) NR: (1)

    The talk was relevant to my job

    1 2(6) 3(21) 4 (27) 5 (20) NR (1)

    Comments:
    •Maybe a bit long (7)
    •Really great and practical- good mix of research info and practical info (2)
    •Esther’s experience, clinical judgment and enthusiasm and her sense of humor are appreciated
    •Enjoyed Enthusiastic (2)
    •A very large proportion of the day should have focused on the theory and evidence behind the approach rather than ‘how to do it’ given how controversial the approach is. (2)
    •Useful information and helpful when parents ask about it’s use.
    •Great presenter- very interesting, still not sure of clinical relevance and concerned therapist will just start taping! (2)
    •Inspiring and new for me! (4)
    •Quite a bit on taping from physio point of view, with loss of impact on drooling
    •More time/info needed on taping and direct connection with droolers
    •Excellent, interesting presentation. Great to have a practical session (2)
    •Limited research and was difficult to understand (3)
    •Relevant and enthusiastic about trying in clinical situation
    •Order of slides was confusing, would have been helpful to have patient populations earlier. Could have added slides on sensory elements discussed
    •No general context of drooling- makes it much harder to make sense of how it might work in practice. (2)
    •I think this was relevant to be included though am not sure it needed to be 2.5 hours long
    •Lots of questions raised by this talk (2)
    •Too much time on non- SLT areas of research
    •Direct application to use by SLT’s would be useful

    Topic 3: RCSLT Update

    The talk was interesting

    1 2 (3) 3(25) 4 (34) 5 (13)

    The talk was relevant to my job

    1 2(1) 3(15) 4 (35) 5 (22) NR (2)

    Comments:
    •Useful (5)
    •I always find RCSLT out of step with life! 35 staff! And they can’t pay specialist Moan/gripe!
    •Still not really sure what RCSLT do for us, but good to have a link with them!
    •Bit dry delivery (2)
    •Too long
    •Not a good forum for this- it should be in Bulletin
    •Would like to get more info (2)
    •Would have liked to have more time to hear about dysphagia competency guidelines
    •Good update back to the team CQlive and dysphagia competency framework

    Topic 4: Feedback from National association of Neonatal Therapy Conference

    The talk was interesting
    1 2 3 4 (27) 5 (48)

    The talk was relevant to my job

    1 (1) 2(5) 3(5) 4 (25) 5 (37) NR (2)

    Comments:
    •Very akin to Gilly Kennedy’s work/course for neonates
    •Great even though I don’t work in acute I work with ex prems 3-19 though so really useful. So fluent considering technical problems (2)
    •So much more information would have been useful- links for community therapists like me who see children who were preterm. (3)
    •She did amazingly well to present without slides, but would love to have them as handouts. (9)
    •Thank you for condensing and whetting appetite for rest of info (3)
    •Longer on this would have been useful. Well done on powering through without the slides (5)
    •Very engaging presentation and interesting topic. I don’t currently work with neonates / preschoolers but enjoyed hearing about it. (3)
    •Good effort with video problems (20
    •Brilliant- very well delivered considering technical glitches- well done siew!
    •I wanted to know more!
    •Some interesting points and more time needed for this talk. It was a bit rushed.
    •Really interesting and relevant to my work (3)
    •Difficult to follow completely without the slides but very engaging talk- made me aware of the stress and trauma of the children with feeding difficulties.
    •Would have like to know more about clinical use- assessment, therapy etc

    Topic 5: Eating and Drinking ability classification system for individuals with cerebral palsy

    The talk was interesting

    1 2 3 (4) 4 (28) 5 (43) NR: 4

    The talk was relevant to my job

    1 2 3(4) 4 (25) 5 (44) NR (2)

    Comments:
    •Brilliant- incredibly helpful and practical (12)
    •Excellent presentation- such a valuable classification system- look forward to more of your research
    •Really useful I saw this at UKSRG conference already- but so good to have it here and more detail this time
    •A copy will be downloaded and used (3)
    •Enjoyed Enthusiastic (2)
    •Great to go back to work with something now to use
    •Not actually something I would use but good to know it’s out there and interesting process
    •Clear and helpful- we love a classification system! Thank you! Good to see if we could extend to other clinical groups.
    •Well done
    •Inspiration to pediatric dysphagia therapists taking on clinically relevant research
    •Brilliant and clear! Must attempt to download and use/try out
    •Will now use this in my assessments
    •Would like to go to chailey and see their feeding team structure
    •Would be great to have more info when research for under 3’s is developed.
    •My team enjoyed helping with the Delphi study

    Overall Rating of the Day:

    1 2(1) 3(3) 4 (38) 5 (27) NR (6)

    Comments:
    •I would support the idea of short case presentations
    •Can you put the ‘Critical Appraisal’ at the end of the conference please- then we have a choice to stay or go- this latest article did nothing to make me want to complete the task- sorry!
    •Someone to feedback from UKSRG conference 2014- it was great.
    •If people are interested in parent interview research of decision making re: gastrostomy I am supervised by DR Gill Craig at City University, who’s done the most in the UK.
    •To have access to the slides before the day -?once you have paid your fee to have in hand for notes.
    •Polling for topics
    •A good mix of topics and opportunity to network. Right mix of formality/ informality to keep order and encourage discussion. Really well organized.
    •Thanks for the brownies and the coffee’s!
    •Future topics:- Duty of care and service provision around parental compliance, difficult cases in paed dysphagia and aspiration.
    -Impact of PEEP CPAP/Vapotherm, optiflow on swallow function
    -If there is a case presentation SIG then it need to relate to any evidence base or theory!
    -Are we at crisis point that band 7 and 8A jobs cannot be filled in paed dysphagia acute v. community/ supervision/training/competence- a day exploring these issues.
    •RCSLT updates could come at the end of SIG so part timers don’t lose clinical talks if they leave early.
    •Great to keep to time but 30min not long enough for lunch!
    •Agree case studies would be helpful- St G’s could do 10 mins on deafblindness and feeding as case review or how to develop feeding service.
    •The suggestion of a ‘shared practice’ session sounds fab- thanks committee!
    •Case studies
    •Always a good opportunity to link up and liaise with other therapists, thank you for your hard work. (2)
    •Afternoon tea break is essential. This has encouraged me to do more reading about current practices and research. Made me aware of the different tools available.
    •Would prefer to start and finish half an hour earlier
    •Time keeping not enforces, leaving aside technical difficulties in the AM, presentations did not start on time and some ran over.
    •I would be happy to do a case study on tube weaning
    •Critical appraisal article on this occasion was not suitable for the audience and maybe a systematic review was not the best choice.
    •Really enjoyed the day- please could we have more notice on proposed topics for the day in order to assess relevance to own job and allow plenty of time to apply for permission. Funding. Train tickets etc
    •Could we have Dr Gillian Craig Speak?
    •Case presentations are a good idea. More feedback from relevant courses please and talks from researchers,
    •I would like to hear small case presentations as suggested during the critical appraisal. I always find the CEN really useful and helps me in my daily practice in York. Thank you

Viewing 1 post (of 1 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Search Articles

Search by keyword, author or date:
[wpdreams_ajaxsearchlite]

Or select a topic from the dropdown list:

Events

Click here to see upcoming events.

Latest News