Home › Forums › PDCEN Meetings › PDSIG May 2013 › SIG feedback

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • Author
    Posts
  • #855
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Please find below the feedback received at from the previous SIG:

    PAEDIATRIC DYSPHAGIA SIG ANALYSIS
    23/05/2013: Dysphagia – A Respiratory focus

    1) Pre SIG organization
    RATING / Participants 1 = 0, 2 = 4, 3 = 6, 4 = 18, 5 = 23, NR = 4

    Comments:
    •The website makes everything so much easier
    •This was my first SIG and everything was very easy and simple
    •Just a bit of uncertainty re: start time. Happy to start at 9:00am but lots of people late
    •Bit late with Agenda
    •Alert to say SIG agenda and booking open would be helpful
    •Would have appreciated email re: registering a place rather than have to keep checking.
    •I didn’t receive any communication- I was unaware of the paper for discussion.
    •Only found out about this SIG via the website- no email notification as a member (with direct debit)
    •Would be useful to advertise better- no response to email sent to SIG committee re: presentations
    •late notice with date

    2) ACCESS
    RATING / Participants 1 = 0, 2 = 0, 3 = 5, 4 = 17, 5 = 30, NR = 4

    Comments:
    •Same venue so it makes it easy
    •Have been before so all ok
    •Details with Agenda
    •Went to wrong place but was directed elsewhere

    3) LOCATION
    RATING / Participants 1 = 3, 2 = 0, 3 = 4, 4 = 19, 5 = 30, NR = 0

    Comments:
    •Very good
    •Preferred old brownies. Would like herbal tea
    •Temperature a bit cold
    •Ok
    •Temperature ok today
    •Morning coffee at 8:45 would be nice
    •Bit warm but nothing you could have done
    •Chairs not very comfortable
    •More seats available for people to sit at lunch
    •Location good- could do with more standing breaks
    •Lecture theatre good- area for coffee too small.
    •Cold in morning, warm in afternoon

    4) ORGANISATION
    RATING / Participants 1 = 0, 2 = 0, 3 = 2, 4 = 23, 5 = 28, NR = 3

    Comments:
    •Good range of presentations
    •I think the critical appraisal/ EBP is hugely important- I like the idea of doing this in a different way to today. Not sure the whole group worked. Perhaps smaller groups to cover more papers so more information to share.
    •Your efforts to provide alternate presentations to cover colleagues who were unavailable were much appreciated!
    •Appreciated last minute case studies in place of cancellation- really interesting
    •Really informed speakers
    •Need sticky labels for people to write their name/place of work on
    •Not stated what time started
    •Late start. I would have gone for coffee had I of known it was a 9:20 start.
    •Thank you for organizing “last minute” case studies etc- very interesting.
    •Would be useful to tell us before a presentation that it is not going to be uploaded.
    •Late start- would like early notification of SLIU dates as other clinics pre-booked long in advance
    •Shame about video but understandable
    •Good time keeping
    •Very interesting just need community as a lot of us work in the community/special schools.
    •Very clinical which was good.
    •Would have been helpful to have handouts on the day or known ahead that it would not be on the website. Article review and case studies helpful. Community focus needs to increase
    •Not clear if to arrive at 9:00 or 9:30- would prefer 9:30
    •This was my first SIG and it was well organized.

    5) SPEAKERS
    RATING / Participants 1 = 0, 2 = 5, 3 = 3, 4 = 22, 5 = 26, NR = 0

    Comments:
    •Respiratory Paed section very interesting
    •Non-availability of advertised speakers was unfortunate. The ones we had were excellent.
    •Presentation from respiratory consultant very interesting- would have been good to have more time on this. RCSLT update also helpful.
    •I like the research articles but could we look at articles that are relevant for more a variety of children on our caseloads i.e. most of us are unlikely to work with children who have dysphagia without known risk factors (i.e. community/special school)
    •Generally very good- I liked the two case studies at the end
    •Really useful to have RCSLT. Good topic for today
    •RCSLT and respiratory consultant useful sessions. May have been useful to discuss more around respiratory conditions- feeding on CPAP or not, vent settings Old paper for discussion! Better to have something that provokes more discussion/ new information but linked to previous talk well. RCSLT and respiratory pediatrician were interesting and informative.
    •Very focuses don acute. Did not understand a lot of the terminology as have only just qualified.
    •An excellent and very varied day. On the whole lively and interesting speakers.
    •Loved variant MDT perspective.
    •I would have appreciated more of an opportunity to speak to RCSLT during their slot (30mins) less presentation
    •Some not as exciting as the others
    •All excellent except X- too many slides
    •Good to see what RCCSLT are doing. All good speakers. Would have like more definitions as assumed a lot of acute knowledge.
    •I enjoyed the talk by the PT. It would have been interesting to know about the evidence around swallowing in ventilator dependent patients as well as hearing about the case studies.
    •RCSLT was a bit dull
    •Some PT specific terms use during PT presentation, which made it difficult to follow at times.
    •Case studies were very interesting and helpful to bring gravity to other speakers. Very good quality of speakers and presentations. Helpful to have some community focus. RCSLT was overwhelming in amount of information. But very informative.
    •Greta to have RCSLT update re: current climate. Quite a lot of jargon in PT and consultant presentation. I am not from an acute background (very interesting though!)
    •Good variety. Good RCSLT came
    •Topics content very useful. Especially the RCSLT presentation of the changes in the NHS
    •RCSLT was particularly good and useful as was
    •X and X were excellent but the others were poor presenters
    •Very interesting topics. Especially appreciate update from RCSLT.
    •Very useful to receive presentations from other relevant medical professionals
    •Excellent
    •Very interesting to have MDT perspective
    •Good to hear from RCSLT and other professionals

    6) REFRESHMENTS
    RATING / Participants 1 = 0, 2 = 2, 3 = 16, 4 = 20, 5 = 18, NR = 0

    Comments:
    •Café wasn’t flagged up but ??? Centre was great, found it by another means
    •Excellent!
    •Any chance of herbal tea?
    •Brownies very rich- old ones preferred
    •Brownies not as good as they used to be.. Would have liked sponsor stalls
    •Great brownies! Good sugar fix to keep me going until lunch time
    •
    •Would be happy to pay a little more and have refreshments before we start
    •Can’t have caffeine- herbal tea would have been appreciated.
    •Morning coffee would be nice
    •Missed previous brownies
    •Herbal teas or hot water to allow for prep of own herbal teas
    •Brownies not as good as previous ones. Tea stations well set out and better kept here
    •Drink on arrival would be nice. Good quality thanks
    •Some juices or hot chocolate please!!

    7) WEBSITE
    RATING / Participants 1 = 1, 2 = 0, 3 = 9, 4 = 16, 5 = 25, NR = 5

    Comments:
    •Couldn’t download previous articles and presentations because I use Mac rather than PC? Would like to be able to print off/access articles and presentations before the SIG- even if only the day before
    •Can all presentations be uploaded please No idea- I don’t use it except to book a place
    •Took a long time for previous presentations to be uploaded. Needs to be more reasons to check website- think course adverts will be good.
    •Will try to use more
    •I am going to access the website more
    •Must go to it more frequently as a good resource
    •Sometimes the presentations go on rather late- but I appreciate the website
    •I haven’t really ad a chance to look at the website just joined the SIG
    •Forum post often not functioning. Late agenda posting
    •Would like more resources, shares of best practice e-learning opportunities
    •Only currently use to book SIG
    •Very difficult to apply to attend SIG and pay. Login details/password a real pain
    •Starting that not all presentations are on the website. Speakers can talk very quickly and so difficult to note info on slides. Would be helpful to have alerts when new info/discussions are posted on the website.
    •Shame not all day lectures will be uploaded but realize that will be that they haven’t been provided
    •Bit difficult to navigate registering a member. Didn’t realize that you have to log in as a member before you can get to ‘member registration’ page
    •It appears sparse when you first access it. Not always easy to navigate eg. Early opening of SIG booking not always matching stated date.
    •Can we have more quick links on the website and a hits counter to monitor it’s use?
    •
    •Really excellent
    •Perhaps a reminder could go out when handouts are uploaded
    •Will try to use more
    •Can the website be set up so that it generates an email when something new is added to it/added to a forum?
    •Can sometimes be difficult to navigate through and find slides of previous SIGS in good time.

    8) I would like to know more about the following areas:

    •Tracheostomy (4)
    •Adolescent transition to adult services
    •Community dysphagia management with adolescents
    •I found the respiratory focus very useful
    •Any outcome measurements/targets that are being used (2)
    •Ventilators- looking at specific client groups
    •Managing ToF’s OA/ laryngeal cleft (especially Type 1 cleft) ENT (5)
    •Acute- pressure changes/ ventilation and swallow assessment
    •Multi-professional feeding clinics- protocol and setting up
    •Ideas to develop MDT dysphagia training
    •Tongue tie update and recommended management
    •Transition to adults. Adherence to advice and ethical issues. Decision making process for NBM/PEG with clinical team and with family.
    •As an acute SLT it would be great to have more of community SLT talks. Sorry cant think of any topics at the top of my head but this SIG is getting more and more ‘acute’ maybe something from special school SLT’s?
    •Neonatal assessment and management
    •Chronic dysphagia- reflux with ventilations/lung involvement
    •What others do in terms of training packages- special schools
    •Progressive conditions
    •Craniofacial (2)
    •Any policies to VF all ventilated children s high-risk groups?
    •Any policies/thoughts on when to feed on or off ventilator?
    •Any thoughts on levels of PEEP and indication of success with speaking valve trials?
    •Any known ventilator feeding questionnaires
    •More difficult to assess- less common signs i.e. place of noisy breathing, feeling rattle in chest, identifying number of breaths pre/post etc VFSS interpretation, assessment methods
    •Talk tools and effectiveness of oral motor therapy on oral control
    •Community/complex needs in special schools (2)
    •Risk management (2)
    •Epilepsy and feeding
    •VFS analysis and swallowing therapy as well as compensatory strategies- maybe drawing on adult work/ literature and applying it to children
    •Thickening fluids- strategies o persuade parents to follow recommendations
    •Sensory feeding issues- especially those where there is not always an obvious cause (i.e. not children with reflux or invasive procedures and not presenting as ASD)
    •Argument about if penetration occurs it doesn’t mean aspiration also occurs
    •Reflux and feeding- at what point do people recommend complete non-oral feeding?
    •Ellie Dodd SENSE gave a presentation at a deafblind SIG I went to on a training program for interveners- this may be helpful aspect to present on for community therapists. The parent perspective at the last SIG was very helpful it would be great to have patient/parent perspective at SIGS (esp if video_
    •Do children ho require long-term ventilation who make it form CPAP to Trache have improvements in ability to manage/tolerate oral feeding?

    9) I would like to ask the following question:

    •Has anyone had success in weaning a child onto oral feeding when they have been in hospital for the first year of life and discharged home on 24 CPAP via nasal prongs and gastrostomy and minimal oral tasters?
    •Is anyone doing a neonatal dysphagia course again?
    •For acute jargon to be routinely explained
    •Could we have shorter lunch breaks in future to allow more time for speakers
    •Review of CA

    #854
    Anonymous
    Inactive

    Hi there,

    I’m Robin and have met some of you before, I run the website on a day-to-day basis. Thanks for all the recent feedback, I’ll try and answer some of the questions here:

    – Mac access – should be fine, am checking with the site developers, some of the uploads will be Word docs therefore you’d need Mac Office (or whatever it is called)…
    – Presentations – we’re entirely at the mercy of the presenters sending through their presentations, we add them as soon as / if we receive them
    – Hits counter – we’re currently trying to access the Google Analytics for the site so can report back to how it is used..
    – Forum notification – at present you choose whether to ‘subscribe’ to a Forum when you first use it, therefore receiving email updates. We originally thought this was better than everyone getting notifications. We are currently looking into giving everyone notifications (which they can then choose to turn off).

    Thanks for using the site, the more you use and engage with the site and the Forum, the better it will get.

    Regards,

    Robin

Viewing 2 posts - 1 through 2 (of 2 total)
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Search Articles

Search by keyword, author or date:
[wpdreams_ajaxsearchlite]

Or select a topic from the dropdown list:

Events

Click here to see upcoming events.

Latest News